Yes, most of the buzz will be about Hamilton’s December sting at Old National Center. And I don’t want to downplay that because the show is worthy of its reputation. (My review of the original company can be found here.)
But Indy is also getting the “Come From Away” relatively early in its run (my thoughts on the Broadway production here). And the surprisingly strong “Anastasia.” And the frivolous but fresh “The Play That Goes Wrong.”
As for the repeats, the “Fiddler on the Roof” tour is based on the recent Broadway revival and features Israeli TV and movie star Yehezkel Lazarov.
As for “Cats,” well, it’s “Cats.” You’ve already made a judgment about that.